Table of Contents

August 17, 2010; 153 (4)

Articles

  • The University of Michigan Health System has fully disclosed medical errors and offered compensation to patients since 2001. Other health systems have been hesitant to adopt similar programs for fear that disclosure could make things worse. This study found a decrease in new legal claims, number of lawsuits per month, time to claim resolution, and costs after implementation of the program compared with before implementation. This experience demonstrates that disclosure with an offer of compensation can be conducted without exacerbating liability claims and costs.

  • Acute renal failure (ARF) requiring dialysis is common among recipients of renal allografts from deceased donors. This multicenter trial randomly assigned deceased donors to intravenous infusion of saline or methylprednisolone at least 3 hours before organ harvesting to determine whether methylprednisolone reduces the incidence and duration of ARF in kidney recipients. Although kidney biopsies from methylprednisolone-treated donors showed suppression of immune response and inflammation, ARF occurred similarly in recipients of methylprednisolone-treated and saline-treated donor organs.

  • Medicare recently proposed quality-of-care measures for chronic hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection. In this analysis of national data, only about 20% of patients with HCV received all recommended care. Performance was lowest for vaccination and highest for pretreatment HCV genotype testing. Of note, patients who received care from both generalists and specialists were more likely to receive recommended care than patients who saw only one type of physician, suggesting that collaboration between generalists and specialists may lead to higher-quality care for patients with HCV.

Academia and Clinic

  • Although traditional end-of-life planning has aimed to have people make treatment decisions in advance of becoming terminally ill, many people find it difficult to predict what medical interventions they would want under such circumstances. These authors advocate for an alternative approach to end-of-life planning that focuses on preparing patients and those close to them to make the best possible in-the-moment medical decisions rather than making decisions about specific interventions ahead of time. They outline practical steps that clinicians can take when providing outpatient care to implement this new approach.

Reviews

  • Mechanical ventilation can result in substantial lung injury related to forces exerted on pulmonary parenchyma and respiratory muscles. This review discusses the evidence of ventilator-induced respiratory muscle injury in animal models and humans, as well as implications for clinical management. The authors suggest that clinicians pay close attention to the contour of the airway pressure waveform when titrating ventilator settings.

  • This systematic review, conducted under the auspices of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality's comparative effectiveness initiative, identified 137 studies providing evidence about operative and nonoperative therapies for rotator cuff injury. Evidence suggests that patients with rotator cuff tears experience improvements in function after undergoing any of several operative procedures or nonoperative therapy, but the amount and strength of available evidence was low for many therapies. Furthermore, sparse comparative data preclude identification of a superior treatment approach.

Perspectives

  • The Miller School of Medicine of the University of Miami and Project Medishare provided a large-scale relief effort in Haiti after the earthquake of 12 January 2010. Academic medical centers in proximity to natural disasters can help deliver effective medical care through a coordinated process involving mobilization of their own resources, establishment of focused management teams at home and on the ground with formal organizational oversight, and partnership with governmental and nongovernmental relief agencies.

Editorials

  • Recent legislation seeks to promote patient safety through confidential error reporting, but the dysfunction in U.S. fault and no-fault injury compensation systems persists. In this issue, Kachalia and colleagues describe the University of Michigan Health System model for disclosure of medical errors and providing compensation to injured patients. This editorial discusses the findings and implications of the article but concludes that more and better data are needed to confirm these findings and convince others to adopt similar programs.

  • The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) introduced the uniform conflict of interest disclosure form in October 2009. The ICMJE member journals piloted the form, encouraged other journals to use it, and invited feedback. At its most recent meeting, the Committee considered the valuable comments received and revised the form. This editorial discusses the updated form, which is available at www.icmje.org.

On Being a Doctor

  • My moment came around 3:00 a.m. during the winter of intern year while I was placing my first central line in the intensive care unit. The senior resident had unintentionally jabbed a large contaminated needle into the hand that I was using to stabilize the ultrasound probe.

  • Practitioners are blinded by time constraints, compassion fatigue, and diverging obligations. Sometimes, just the act of laying fresh eyes on a patient and seeing the case from a different perspective can result in a very different outcome.

Letters

Ad Libitum

Medical Notices

Summaries for Patients

ACP Journal Club