Table of Contents

December 16, 2008; 149 (12)

Articles

  • Tosteson and colleagues used data from SPORT (Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial)—which found that patients who had surgery for spinal stenosis or degenerative spondylolisthesis had better outcomes over 2 years than patients who did not have surgery—to estimate the cost-effectiveness of surgery. Surgery for spinal stenosis costs about $77 000 per quality-adjusted life-year gained, and surgery for degenerative spondylolisthesis costs about $115 000 per quality-adjusted life-year gained. However, the cost-effectiveness could change if patients are followed over a longer period.

  • Many persons in the United States experience interruptions in their health insurance coverage. Bindman and coworkers found an association between interruptions in coverage and a higher rate of hospitalization for ambulatory care–sensitive conditions, such as heart failure, diabetes, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, among hospitalized California adults with Medicaid. Policies that reduce interruptions in coverage might prevent some of these hospitalizations.

  • Physicians caring for critically ill patients are often reluctant to discuss poor prognoses with family members. In interviews about discussing prognosis of patients in intensive care units, 95% of surrogate decision makers felt that avoiding discussions about prognosis was an unacceptable way to maintain hope. A theme that emerged from the interviews was that timely discussion of prognosis is essential to prepare emotionally and logistically for a loved one's death.

  • Pulmonary rehabilitation programs improve outcomes, but access to outpatient, hospital-based programs is very limited. In a 10-center, Canadian noninferiority trial, Maltais and coworkers randomly assigned 252 patients to home-based or outpatient, hospital-based exercise training for 8 weeks. At 1 year, both interventions had reduced dyspnea by the same amount, as measured on the dyspnea subscale of the Chronic Respiratory Questionnaire. Home-based pulmonary rehabilitation may be a reasonable alternative to hospital-based programs.

Academia and Clinic

  • Lefflang and colleagues present some recent developments in how to conduct systematic reviews of diagnostic test accuracy studies. Investigators conducting such reviews should avoid restrictive electronic search filters and summary quality scores, use methods for meta-analysis that account for the paired nature of the estimates and their dependence on threshold, and use the hierarchical summary receiver-operating characteristic or the bivariate model for analysis of the data. Challenges in diagnostic test accuracy research include poor reporting of and difficulties in interpreting the results of systematic reviews.

Review

  • Kriston and colleagues examined whether a 3- or 10-item questionnaire (Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test– Consumption [AUDIT-C] or AUDIT) better identifies unhealthy alcohol use in adults. They found 14 studies that directly compared the accuracy of the 2 questionnaires. These studies, conducted mainly in primary care settings, used different reference standards and had heterogeneous findings. Some pooled analyses suggested that primary care patients with a positive result on AUDIT were more likely than those with a positive result on AUDIT-C to be engaging in risky drinking. The evidence suggests, but does not prove, that AUDIT may be better in some settings for identifying unhealthy alcohol use in adults.

Abroad

  • West discusses the Qinghai–Tibet Railway—which travels for more than 14 hours at an average altitude of 4500 m, the highest point being 5072 m (16 600 ft)—and the engineering feat in oxygenating the whole train. The medical challenges during construction of the track and in protecting the passengers against hypoxia are impressive, and the completion of the railway was one of the most ambitious high-altitude engineering projects to date.

Editorials

  • The 2-year analyses by Tosteson and colleagues in this issue suggest that decompressive surgery without fusion for spinal stenosis offers good value and that fusion surgery for spondylolisthesis offers less value for its cost than other interventions. This work is critically important in the context of limited resources and seemingly unlimited costly therapies for chronic disease. However, the jury is still out about whether the benefits of spine surgery justify the investment.

  • In this issue, Leeflang and colleagues sort through the issues associated with systematic reviews of diagnostic test accuracy studies and conclude that test accuracy depends on its immediate clinical context. Also in this issue, Kriston and associates—who compared the diagnostic accuracy of AUDIT and AUDIT-C—illustrate that comparing the performance of diagnostic tests within the context of their use in practice gives clinicians a better idea of how a test may perform in practice. Herein lies the Holy Grail: Link evidence on diagnostic test accuracy to clinical practice.

On Being a Doctor

  • I always wanted to be the family doctor. That is not to say that I regret my decision to be an internist. But my vision of being a doctor always included an image of my mother, otoscope in hand, examining a cousin or neighbor at our dining room table. She was our family's doctor.

Letters

Thanks to Reviewers

Medical Notices

Summaries for Patients

ACP Journal Club