Are Pay-for-Performance Programs a Threat to Medical Professionalism?

  1. Paulette Metoyer, MD
  1. From Ann Arbor, MI 48113.

    TO THE EDITOR:

    It was gratifying to read Snyder and Neubauer's position paper (1) on pay-for-performance and to see that I am not alone in my concerns over these initiatives. I would like to comment on a few issues.

    First, health care providers are the only certain beneficiaries of pay-for-performance. Therefore, the implementation of pay-for-performance programs, without evidence of patient benefit, is inconsistent with the ethical imperative that “[c]linicians must ensure that … a medically appropriate level of care takes precedence over personal consideration” (1). In that regard, pay-for-performance seems inherently unethical.

    Second, the …

    « Previous | Next Article »Table of Contents