Substituted Judgment and the Decision to Withhold Life Support

  1. Kenneth N. Scissors, MD; and
  2. Colleen Butler Scissors, JD
  1. 1710 NE Stanton Avenue Portland, OR 97212

    Excerpt

    To the Editors: The results of the provocative study by Seckler and colleagues (1) lack generalizability because of two major flaws in the study design. The investigators' choice of study setting, an urban geriatrics teaching clinic, introduces pre-selection bias into the study, and their use of a single-interviewer method creates an uncontrolled confounder (2).

    In contrast to patients in previous studies (3), most of those (67%) in the study by Seckler and colleagues answered "yes" when asked whether they wanted to be resuscitated if they were no longer able to recognize family and friends and if they had a sudden

    This 100-word excerpt has been provided in the absence of an abstract.

    | Table of Contents
    Most Read Most Read
    Most Commented Most Commented On
    Annals in the News Annals in the News
    Clinical Trials Clinical Trials
    Comparative Effectiveness Comparative Effectiveness
    Hospital Medicine Hospital Medicine
    • Advertisement
    • Advertisement