Annals
Established in 1927 by the American College of Physicians
:
Advanced search
 
box Article
 arrow  Table of Contents                
space
 arrow  PDF of this article
(PDFs free after 6 months)
space
 arrow  Related articles in Annals
space
 arrow  Articles citing this article
space
box Services
 arrow  Send comment/rapid response letter
space
 arrow  Notify a friend about this article
space
 arrow  Alert me when this article is cited
space
 arrow  Add to Personal Archive
space
 arrow  Download to Citation Manager
space
 arrow  ACP Search                        
space
 arrow  Get Permissions
space
box Google Scholar
 arrow  Search for Related Content
space
box PubMed
Articles in PubMed by Author:
  arrow  Graner, J.
space
 arrow  Related Articles in PubMed
space
 arrow  PubMed Citation
space
 arrow  PubMed
space

REPLY

Physicians and Patient Spirituality

right arrow John Graner, MD

7 August 2001 | Volume 135 Issue 3 | Page 220


IN RESPONSE:

It is perfectly valid to base one's public conduct on religious principles. Thus, I don't object to Dr. Bodey allowing his religious beliefs to dictate his actions in broad ethical terms, as long as he does not impose his particular belief structure on others. This is obviously a separate issue from the display of religious icons in a clinic office. To the extent that this office is a site of medical care for those of all faiths and creeds, it represents a segment of the secular, public space. As opposed to many other world cultures, secularization, that is, the separation of church and politics, is an accomplished fact in our society. This has caused religion to lose the political elements it once possessed in the western world. Of course, this does not mean that religion has become an entirely private affair, either (1): "The public-secular domain, or the political sphere, properly speaking, comprehends and has room for the public-religious sphere. A believer can be a member of a church and at the same time act as a citizen in the larger unit constituted by all belonging to the City." The word "all" is key in the preceding sentence. The display of a religious icon in a secular setting cannot help but make a political statement in addition to a religious one. I know for a fact (because I have asked them) that many of our patients, domestic as well as foreign, would consider it an insult to see a Christian religious icon hanging in the examining room of a secular medical clinic. Such a display would be appropriate only in a closed religious community in which physician and patients shared the same religious convictions, a "pseudo-theocratic" setting. Dr. Bodey is assuming that his non-Christian patients are open-minded enough to excuse his self-focused display of religiosity. In most cases, perhaps they are, but why put them to the test? Dr. Bodey also asks if the display of religious symbols in the office is somehow akin to the display of "sports symbols." Personally, it is difficult for me to conceive of two more disparate types of objects. I believe most religious persons would agree with me on that point!


Author and Article Information
space
up arrowTop
dotAuthor & Article Info
down arrowReference

Mayo Clinic; Rochester, MN 55905 (Graner)


Reference
space
up arrowTop
up arrowAuthor & Article Info
dotReference

1. Arendt H. The concept of history. In: Between Past and Future. New York: Penguin Books; 1987:41-90.

About Letters
space

The Editors welcome submissions for possible publication in the Letters section. Authors of letters should:

•Include no more than 300 words of text, three authors, and five references

•Type with double-spacing

•Send three copies of the letter, an authors' form signed by all authors, and a cover letter describing any conflicts of interest related to the contents of the letter.

Letters commenting on an Annals article will be considered if they are received within 6 weeks of the time the article was published. Only some of the letters received can be published. Published letters are edited and may be shortened; tables and figures are included only selectively. Authors will be notified that the letter has been received. If the letter is selected for publication, the author will be notified about 3 weeks before the publication date. Unpublished letters cannot be returned.

Annals welcomes electronically submitted letters.


Related articles in Annals:

Letters
Physicians and Patient Spirituality
John Graner
Annals 2000 133: 748. [Full Text]  

Letters
Physicians and Patient Spirituality
Gerald P. Bodey
Annals 2001 135: 220. [Full Text]  

Letters
Physicians and Patient Spirituality
Susan B. LeGrand
Annals 2002 137: 372. [Full Text]  

Letters
Physicians and Patient Spirituality
John Graner
Annals 2002 137: 372. [Full Text]  

Letters
Physicians and Patient Spirituality
Fritz Baumgartner
Annals 2003 138: 690-691. [Full Text]  



This article has been cited by other articles:


Home page
ANN INTERN MEDHome page
F. Baumgartner
Physicians and Patient Spirituality
Ann Intern Med, April 15, 2003; 138(8): 690 - 691.
[Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
ANN INTERN MEDHome page
S. B. LeGrand
Physicians and Patient Spirituality
Ann Intern Med, September 3, 2002; 137(5_Part_1): 372 - 372.
[Full Text] [PDF]


box Article
 arrow  Table of Contents                
space
 arrow  PDF of this article
(PDFs free after 6 months)
space
 arrow  Related articles in Annals
space
 arrow  Articles citing this article
space
box Services
 arrow  Send comment/rapid response letter
space
 arrow  Notify a friend about this article
space
 arrow  Alert me when this article is cited
space
 arrow  Add to Personal Archive
space
 arrow  Download to Citation Manager
space
 arrow  ACP Search                        
space
 arrow  Get Permissions
space
box Google Scholar
 arrow  Search for Related Content
space
box PubMed
Articles in PubMed by Author:
  arrow  Graner, J.
space
 arrow  Related Articles in PubMed
space
 arrow  PubMed Citation
space
 arrow  PubMed
space


 Home | Current Issue | Past Issues | In the Clinic | ACP Journal Club | CME | Collections | Audio/Video | Mobile | Subscribe | Tools | Help | ACP Online