Annals
Established in 1927 by the American College of Physicians
:
Advanced search
 
box Article
 arrow  Table of Contents                
space
box Services
 arrow  Send comment/rapid response letter
space
 arrow  Notify a friend about this article
space
 arrow  Alert me when this article is cited
space
 arrow  Add to Personal Archive
space
 arrow  Download to Citation Manager
space
 arrow  ACP Search                        
space
 arrow  Get Permissions
space
box Google Scholar
 arrow  Search for Related Content
space
box PubMed
Articles in PubMed by Author:
  arrow  Farwell, B.
space
 arrow  Related Articles in PubMed
space
 arrow  PubMed Citation
space
 arrow  PubMed
space

REPLY

Health Care in America: An Intimate Glimpse

right arrow Byron Farwell

1 June 1997 | Volume 126 Issue 11 | Page 922


IN RESPONSE:

A curious letter: beginning with "compassionate care" and ending with "you get what you pay for." Suggesting, it seems, that if Americans want compassionate care they must pay for it.

Although I made no mention of how-or even if-I paid my hospital and the surgeon's bill, Dr. Ganem assumes that I am unwilling to pay for my health care. However, didn't the "Medicare population" pay into Social Security for many years? And weren't their dollars worth more than today's dollars?

But he's right. There has got to be a better way. The Eskimos, they say, once had a cheaper, more effective method for handling the worthless old: They put them on ice floes. This saves paying doctors and hospitals to keep these miserly people alive.

Judging by the response, my article seems to have hit a resonating cord. Dr. Ganem is the only disgruntled reader heard from so far. Doctors tell me that even doctors, when patients, are ill treated. A retired hospital director wrote: "mea culpa."

It has been suggested that perhaps European hospitals are now as bad and expensive as U.S. hospitals. Not so, it would seem. One physician sent me a clipping from The New York Times, a letter to the editor by a man who shopped around for his ureterolithotomy. The lowest price he could find in the United States was $12 000 for surgery and 4 days in the hospital. He went to Rouen, France, where he had excellent surgery and spent 7 days in the hospital for $2000.

A friend of mine who lives part time in France tells me that she recently had an appendectomy there for $1800 and enjoyed wine with excellent meals in a lovely room overlooking a pretty green courtyard. She contrasted this with her earlier treatment in a New York hospital where, when a rash developed on her back, she was handed a tube of Vaseline and told to apply it herself.

Are old people alone responsible for the "progressive bastardization of health care"? Don't doctors and nurses have something to do with the quality of health care? Are they interested? In the most recent issue of American Scholar, Dr. Paul R. McHugh at Johns Hopkins writes that "the aim of medicine cannot simply be to prevent suffering. ... The elimination of suffering is a veterinarian rather than a medical goal." That seems, as the young say, way harsh. Perhaps an ice floe isn't all that bad.


Author and Article Information
space
up arrowTop
dotAuthor & Article Info

Hillsboro, VA 20134

About Letters
space

The Editors welcome submissions for possible publication in the Letters section. Authors of letters should:

•Include no more than 300 words of text, three authors, and five references

•Type with double-spacing

•Send three copies of the letter, an authors' form signed by all authors, and a cover letter describing any conflicts of interest related to the contents of the letter.

Letters commenting on an Annals article will be considered if they are received within 6 weeks of the time the article was published. Only some of the letters received can be published. Published letters are edited and may be shortened; tables and figures are included only selectively. Authors will be notified that the letter has been received. If the letter is selected for publication, the author will be notified about 3 weeks before the publication date. Unpublished letters cannot be returned.

Annals welcomes electronically submitted letters.





box Article
 arrow  Table of Contents                
space
box Services
 arrow  Send comment/rapid response letter
space
 arrow  Notify a friend about this article
space
 arrow  Alert me when this article is cited
space
 arrow  Add to Personal Archive
space
 arrow  Download to Citation Manager
space
 arrow  ACP Search                        
space
 arrow  Get Permissions
space
box Google Scholar
 arrow  Search for Related Content
space
box PubMed
Articles in PubMed by Author:
  arrow  Farwell, B.
space
 arrow  Related Articles in PubMed
space
 arrow  PubMed Citation
space
 arrow  PubMed
space


 Home | Current Issue | Past Issues | In the Clinic | ACP Journal Club | CME | Collections | Audio/Video | Mobile | Subscribe | Tools | Help | ACP Online