Article    Table of Contents                    Full Text of this article Free    Figures/Tables List  Services    Send comment/rapid response letter    Notify a friend about this article    Alert me when this article is cited    Add to Personal Archive    Download to Citation Manager    ACP Search                            Get Permissions  Google Scholar    Search for Related Content  PubMed Articles in PubMed by Author:    Asch, D. A.    Hershey, J. C.    Related Articles in PubMed    PubMed Citation    PubMed

ACADEMIA AND CLINIC

Why Some Health Policies Don't Make Sense at the Bedside

David A. Asch and John C. Hershey

1 June 1995 | Volume 122 Issue 11 | Pages 846-850

Cost-effectiveness analysis and other forms of decision analysis are becoming more common in the medical literature and are increasingly influential in the development of health policy. Nevertheless, many clinicians find it difficult to apply policies developed from these analyses to individual encounters with patients. We examine the assumptions behind these analyses and argue that the perspective they embody can make clinical strategies appear to be less risky in theory than they are at the bedside. We believe that this problem underlies the intuitive concern many physicians have about policy analyses and calls into question the value of these analyses in shaping clinical practice. These analyses aggregate the benefits and burdens of alternative interventions across different individual persons. Thus, overall population risk appears blunted, as it would in a diversified portfolio of stocks that react differently to financial forces or in a herd of cattle that react differently to veterinary interventions. The assumptions behind these analyses make sense if aggregate outcome is what matters, but not if one cares about each individual investment or animal. Because such aggregation tends to understate individual risk, when applied to human health policy, it may misrepresent the interests of patients and cannot be assumed to provide useful guidelines for decision making at the bedside.

Author and Article Information

From the Veterans Affairs Medical Center and the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Requests for Reprints: David A. Asch, MD, Division of General Internal Medicine, 317 Ralston-Penn Center, 3615 Chestnut Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104-2676.
Acknowledgments: The authors thank Robert A. Aronowitz, MD; Michael L. DeKay, PhD; Arthur Elstein, PhD; Jose J. Escarce, MD; Jeffrey H. Silber, MD, PhD; Gail Slap, MD; Peter Ubel, MD; and Sankey V. Williams, MD, for critical reviews of earlier drafts of the manuscript.
Grant Support: In part by grants R011HG00616 and R011HG00621 from the National Center for Human Genome Research. Dr. Asch is the recipient of a Department of Veterans Affairs Health Services Research and Development Service Career Development Award.

This article has been cited by other articles:

				D. P. Sulmasy Cancer Care, Money, and the Value of Life: Whose Justice? Which Rationality? J. Clin. Oncol., January 10, 2007; 25(2): 217 - 222. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				R. G. Holloway, S. P. Ringel, J. L. Bernat, C. M. Keran, and B. L. Lawyer US neurologists: Attitudes on rationing Neurology, November 28, 2000; 55(10): 1492 - 1497. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				A. M. Bayoumi and D. A. Redelmeier Decision Analysis with Cumulative Prospect Theory Med Decis Making, October 1, 2000; 20(4): 404 - 411. [Abstract] [PDF]

				E. I. Bluth, J. H. Sunshine, J. B. Lyons, C. A. Beam, L. A. Troxclair, L. Althans-Kopecky, P. E. Crewson, M. A. Sullivan, D. H. Smetherman, P. A. Heidenreich, et al. Power Doppler Imaging: Initial Evaluation as a Screening Examination for Carotid Artery Stenosis Radiology, June 1, 2000; 215(3): 791 - 800. [Abstract] [Full Text]

				D. J. Seidenwurm, C. H. McDonnell III, N. Raghavan, and J. Breslau Cost Utility Analysis of Radiographic Screening for an Orbital Foreign Body before MR Imaging AJNR Am. J. Neuroradiol., February 1, 2000; 21(2): 426 - 433. [Abstract] [Full Text]

				M. L. Dekay, C. A.E. Nickerson, P. A. Ubel, J. C. Hershey, M. D. Spranca, and D. A. Asch Further Explorations of Medical Decisions for Individuals and for Groups Med Decis Making, January 1, 2000; 20(1): 39 - 44. [Abstract] [PDF]

				T. Greenhalgh Narrative based medicine: Narrative based medicine in an evidence based world BMJ, January 30, 1999; 318(7179): 323 - 325. [Full Text]

				J. G. Dolan A Method for Evaluating Health Care Providers' Decision Making: The Provider Decision Process Assessment Instrument Med Decis Making, January 1, 1999; 19(1): 38 - 41. [Abstract] [PDF]

				D. J. Cher and L. A. Lenert Rapid Approximation of Confidence Intervals for Markov Process Decision Models: Applications in Decision Support Systems J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc., July 1, 1997; 4(4): 301 - 312. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				D. J. Cher, J. Miyamoto, and L. A. Lenert Incorporating Risk Attitude into Markov-process Decision Models:: Importance for Individual Decision Making Med Decis Making, July 1, 1997; 17(3): 340 - 350. [Abstract] [PDF]

				D. A. Asch and P. A. Ubel Rationing by Any Other Name N. Engl. J. Med., June 5, 1997; 336(23): 1668 - 1671. [Full Text]

				B. J. Cohen Assigning Values to Intermediate Health States for Cost-Utility Analysis: Theory and Practice Med Decis Making, October 1, 1996; 16(4): 376 - 385. [Abstract] [PDF]

				E. C. Schneider and A. M. Epstein Influence of Cardiac-Surgery Performance Reports on Referral Practices and Access to Care -- A Survey of Cardiovascular Specialists N. Engl. J. Med., July 25, 1996; 335(4): 251 - 256. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				R. McNutt Accelerated tPA versus Streptokinase for Suspected Myocardial Infarction: Waiting for our Mountian Dew Med Decis Making, October 1, 1995; 15(4): 395 - 396. [PDF]